The Resilience of the Paint Sector in Home Improvement

In the vast and varied world of home improvement, paint has always held a place of prominence. As the industry navigates through the economic ebbs and flows of 2024, the paint sector showcases a fascinating tale of resilience, innovation, and shifting consumer loyalty.

Painting a room is one of the most affordable and straightforward home improvement projects with transformative potential. Unlike major renovations or structural changes, painting requires minimal investment in terms of both time and money, making it accessible to homeowners on various budgets. Additionally, the process of painting a room is relatively simple and can often be completed over a weekend with basic tools and minimal expertise making it a popular choice for DIY enthusiasts and budget-conscious homeowners alike.

While the broader home improvement market has faced its challenges, with growth decelerating to a mere 0.7% in 2023, the paint category remains a vibrant spot. Home Depot, a longstanding leader in this space, has seen a slight dip in its market share from 34% to 32% over two years. This adjustment speaks volumes about the competitive pressures from rivals Lowe's and Sherwin-Williams, both of whom have notched up their share by 1pp and 2pp respectively.

Despite the overall market's downturn, Sherwin-Williams and Ace Hardware have painted a different picture, recording positive year-over-year increases in unit share between 6% and 8%. This growth underscores the enduring appeal of quality paint products and the brand loyalty they can engender. Sherwin-Williams, in particular, has solidified its position through exceptional customer retention, boasting a 93% wallet share among its buyers—a testament to the strength of its brand and the trust it has cultivated.

The dynamics within the paint sector reflect broader trends influencing consumer choices and brand strategies. Home Depot's exclusive brand, Behr, has faced a slight contraction, indicating the fierce competition and the high stakes involved in maintaining market share. On the flip side, Sherwin-Williams' partnership with Lowe's and its dominant brand share growth from 55% to 58% exemplify how strategic collaborations and a strong brand proposition can lead to success in a crowded marketplace.

The resilience of the paint sector amidst broader industry challenges is a harbinger of the potential that lies in understanding and adapting to consumer preferences. The shifting landscape, marked by digital transformation and evolving consumer expectations, calls for brands to innovate continually and retailers to offer a mix of quality, value, and experience that resonates with today’s consumer.

 As we move forward, the paint sector's resilience is likely to spur further innovation, from eco-friendly formulations to advanced application technologies. Brands that can navigate this evolving landscape with agility and foresight will not only capture the imagination of consumers but also paint a brighter future for the home improvement industry at large.

In the end, the story of paint in the home improvement industry is one of enduring relevance. It reminds us that even in a digital age, the fundamental desire to create, improve, and personalize our living spaces remains a potent force—one that continues to drive market dynamics and inspire innovation.

Read YipitData’s FY24 State of the Home Improvement report to further unpack changing dynamics in the home improvement industry.

Need SKU-level insights for your category?